Theatrical training and storytelling?
So I joined an internet google discussion group for Professional Storytellers, and a question was raised I felt was worth responding to: Do you need theatrical training to be a storyteller. My response is below, and I would love to hear your thoughts on my response. As I try to establish myself in the world, I am currently questioning what it is I do do and what it is I want to do. I know I want to be a storyteller, but how is that done is the question. Well, that’s my question, I hope all is well for you and all the best finding the answers you need, cause I’m sure you have a lot of questions as well. Enjoy it all!
David, thank you for bring a good question to the forum. And thank you to everyone who has responded, it reads as if a lot of thought has gone into these responses, and I would like to add my own thoughts as well as build on the question by asking another question.
First my thoughts on theatrical training and storytelling: In brief, NO, theatrical training is not necessary (Kathryn Windham, Ray Hicks, and so on…). Does theatrical training help with storytelling? As has been mentioned in several previous responses, yes, it can. I began my exploration of the performance arts through theater, and it was through the theater that I was introduced to storytelling. There are many technical skills that a theatrical training introduces that are bennificial in storytelling (ie. stage presence, stage vocal work, diction, physical stage movement if your into that). I also feel, as Rivka (I love your name) mentioned, that theatrical training can become a burden to storytelling. While storytelling is a performance, it is also about dismantling that “forth wall.” I have found in theater, even one person shows, there is a barrier between the performer and the audience. If the character is speaking to the audience, it feels as if they are not speaking to you directly, but to the character they have defined you as representing. As I study storytelling I am recognizing the importance of not performing for the audience, but giving the story to the audience. There seems to be an undefined technique (at least not clearly defined as far as I know) to storytelling that is about transcend the immediate performance and move into (for lack of a better location name) the realm of the story. So, in answer to the first question, I suggest theatrical training can help as long as you recognize it is Theatrical training, and not storytelling – I feel it is essential to differentiate (as a side note: I highly recommend watching Jay O’Callahan [on DVD is he isn’t planning any Icelandic Tours] for a performer who masterfully walks the line between theater and storytelling).
And now for the second part of my response, the question: In the digital discussion that has been inspired by this question, it seems we are all beating around the bush of an essential question to contemporary storytelling: what is it? How do we define “a storyteller”? I read several responses suggesting storytelling comes from having the passion, the fire for stories burn inside you, and frankly, those sorts of answers bother me. The definition is too unspecific; open to such subjective interpretation that it loses all meaning.
I believe it was Rachel who cited how loosely the term “storyteller” is tossed about Hollywood, and I think until there is a clear defining of what it means to be a storyteller we cannot reasonably criticize the overuse of the term. Personally, if I am told “Oh, Stephen Spielberg is such a great storyteller,” I will quickly respond “Hell no he isn’t. Spielberg is a film director, be he great or be he not so great, that’s a preference issue, but he certainly isn’t a storyteller.” The Spielberg advocate may then counter my impassioned response with, “Well then, what is a storyteller.” I have no recourse at this point. If “to be a storyteller” is not defined, I cannot argue what I feel is a misuse of the term.
I do have some thoughts on that question, and it may soon be time to articulate those. First, however, I’d like to open the question to all here: What is a storyteller? It seems we can agree that you don’t need theatrical training, so what does it mean to be trained as a storyteller. Are there any defined techniques? Is there a sort of “method storytelling” (ie. “I subscribe to the Claflinesk technique, as I have this strange fascination with the imbecility of mooses” or “I tend to take a Windhamian approach to my work”)? Please note, I mean those examples only half satirically. I feel a storytelling technique or techniques should be in some way defined so we, as artists, can better communicate with mainstream culture as a whole and interact with critics on a clearer level. Just my thoughts.
Lethan Candlish
www.travelingtales.net